Western Fine Jewelry Mystery Piece

A little mystery, a lot of western. Choose your tier and let us surprise you with one genuine western jewelry piece selected from our western fine jewelry assortment.

Signature — $89.99

An everyday favorite with western character. Your mystery selection may be a pair of earrings, a necklace, a ring, or another jewelry piece from our Signature assortment. The regular retail value of your selection will meet or exceed $89.99.

Luxe — $124.99

A little extra indulgence. Your mystery selection comes from our higher-value assortment, chosen for its stone, craftsmanship, or design details. You may receive a pair of earrings, a necklace, a ring, or another jewelry piece from our Luxe assortment. The regular retail value of your selection will meet or exceed $124.99.

Choose your ring size, just in case. Select your ring size from 5–10 so we have your preference if a ring is selected. Choosing a ring size does not guarantee that you will receive a ring.

Each purchase includes one mystery jewelry selection (earrings are supplied as a pair). The exact style and jewelry type are a surprise. Metals and findings vary by piece and may include sterling silver, copper, or other materials; not every piece is entirely sterling silver. Natural stone color and matrix vary, making each selection unique. Stones may be spiny oyster, turquoise, freshwater pearls, or other semi-precious stones.

Mystery Item Disclaimer: All mystery items are final sale and cannot be returned or exchanged. If your order arrives damaged, defective or incorrect, please contact us so we can make it right.

Do y’all offer free shipping?
We sure do—orders over $150 (for eligible items) ship free via ground. Some exclusions may apply.

Which carriers do you use, and what’s it cost?
For smaller orders, you’ll choose USPS or UPS at checkout. Real-time rates and estimated delivery times pop up right there. (Delivery time starts once your order's packed and ready.)

When will my order ship?
In-stock items ship in 1–5 business days. Drop-ship items (those that ship straight from the maker) take 7–21 business days to leave the warehouse. Transit time depends on your shipping choice.

Where do y’all ship from?
Our in-stock items ship from our warehouse in Sylvania, Ohio.

Can I shop in person or pick up my order?
No in-store shopping at the moment—we’re all online, all the time.

• Free shipping? Yep—orders $150+ (on qualifying items) ship free with ground service.
• Size charts: You’ll find size info on most product pages—just scroll down and check under the description.
• Processing time: In-stock goodies ship in 1–5 biz days. Drop-ship items take 7–21 biz days. Carrier time comes after that.
• Returns: Start your return in our Return Portal within 30 days of delivery for a refund, exchange, or store credit. Holiday orders placed October 15–December 25 have an extended return-request deadline of January 10. Returns requested beyond the standard 30 days are eligible for exchange or store credit only between those dates. Your full 30-day window still applies if it ends after January 10.
• Heads up: We’re online-only. No in-store shopping (our warehouse is in Sylvania, OH).

Have additional questions? Check our full Frequently Asked Questions